Skip to content

Dear customers! Please send orders and inquiries to [email protected] or to Telegram @servix_uz instead of calling by phone: due to the high workload, the operator cannot answer all incoming calls.

Servix

Storage system or NAS: what to choose for an office and a company

Servix technical team · Updated

In brief. For shared folders and office backup, a NAS-class solution is used — file storage over SMB and NFS; in the Servix catalog this role is filled by a server with drives: a refurbished Dell T350 with four 22 TB drives provides 44 TB in RAID 10 for 51,676,644 UZS. A block storage system with two controllers — HPE MSA 2060/2062 or Dell PowerVault ME5 — is needed when one volume is shared by several hosts of a VMware, Proxmox or Hyper-V cluster or by a DBMS cluster. A terabyte on a storage system is noticeably more expensive: a dual-controller HPE MSA 2060 iSCSI 12LFF without drives costs 93,084,000 UZS — almost as much as a file server with twelve 8 TB drives, which provides 80 TB in RAID 6 for 94,100,460 UZS. With a storage system, you pay for the second controller and shared host access, not for capacity.

The question “storage system or NAS” usually arises in two situations: the shared folder on an old server has filled up, or the company is installing a second virtualization host. The theory of architectures has already been covered in the articles “How to choose a storage system” and “SAN, NAS or all-flash”. This article is about the purchase decision: which task to solve with what, where the line between network storage and a block array lies, how much a terabyte costs in each option and who maintains it all afterwards. It is written for IT managers and administrators choosing between a box with drives, a server and a dual-controller array.

The three options people actually choose from

A NAS device of the Synology or QNAP class is a ready-made box with its own operating system. It provides network folders over SMB and NFS, and many models support iSCSI volumes, backup and synchronization. Inside there is one system board, and it can be configured from a web interface in an evening.

A file server is a regular server with a cage for 3.5-inch drives, a RAID controller and Windows Server or Linux (Samba, TrueNAS). Functionally it is the same NAS, only built from server components: ECC memory, iDRAC or iLO remote management, a controller with cache, usually two hot-swap power supplies. Any part can be replaced, and it is configured by your administrator.

A block storage system is an HPE MSA 2060/2062 or Dell PowerVault ME5. It is not a “big NAS.” The array presents not folders but volumes (LUNs) to hosts over Fibre Channel, iSCSI or SAS, and the file system on them is created by the hypervisor or server. In HPE QuickSpecs for the MSA 2060, the access type is written exactly that way — Block. Dell, in the ME5 specification, calls the array a block SAN/DAS and supports file access through a separate Windows-based NAS of the NX series. On the other hand, inside there are two controllers that stand in for each other, and separate paths to each host.

There are no ready-made Synology or QNAP NAS devices in the Servix catalog, and we will not pretend there are. For us, the NAS role is filled by a server used as file storage — kits and capacity calculations are collected in the selection “File server and backup server”. If a shared volume for several hosts is needed — a block storage system.

Task → what to take

Task

What to choose

Why not the other

Shared folders and office documents for 10–⁠100 people

A tower file server with 4–⁠8 3.5″ drives, or a NAS device

A storage system does not share folders without a server, and office files do not need a second controller

Backups of servers and PCs

A separate backup server with an LFF cage, not in the domain; NAS as a second copy

Copies on the same server or storage system as the data will be lost along with it

Shared disks for a VMware, Proxmox or Hyper-V cluster of two or more hosts

Block storage system with two controllers: SAS for 2–⁠4 hosts, iSCSI 10/25GbE or FC for more

NFS storage on a single board — a common point of failure for all virtual machines

Video archive

1–⁠2 recording servers — a server with 8–⁠12 LFF drives; many recording servers and hundreds of terabytes — an LFF storage system with expansion shelves

Video is sequential writing of large volumes; the price per terabyte decides

1C or SQL database on a single server

Local SSDs in the DBMS server

A network to the array adds latency and cost with no benefit

DBMS cluster with a shared disk

Block storage system with SSDs: Dell ME5024 or HPE MSA 2062

Both nodes must see the shared volume; a network folder is not suitable for this

Files and virtualization together

A storage system for the cluster, with the file server as a virtual machine in it

Folders get the same fault tolerance as the other VMs, without a second storage

The last row is the most common scenario in a company of 50–⁠200 people. A separate NAS next to the cluster duplicates storage and adds one more box that has to be looked after. A file server as a VM on a storage system volume moves between hosts together with the other machines.

Hypervisors can technically run on a NAS too: vSphere connects datastores over NFS 3 and 4.1, Hyper-V stores machines on SMB 3.0 shares, and Proxmox works with NFS and SMB as shared storage. For a test bench this is fine. For production, the limitation is not the protocol but the single board: rebooting the NAS for an update stops all virtual machines at once.

The block option has its own peculiarity in Proxmox. A shared volume from a storage system over iSCSI, FC or SAS is connected to the cluster via LVM, and virtual machine snapshots on such storage appeared only in Proxmox VE 9 — still with technology preview status. If snapshots are critical for you, check this before buying.

Fault tolerance: one board or two controllers

RAID protects only against drive failure. A NAS device and a file server have a single system board, controller and operating system. If the board burns out, the data is intact but unavailable until the repair or until it is restored from a copy on another machine. For office documents this is often acceptable if a copy exists and the recovery time is known in advance.

In a storage system, two controllers work simultaneously (active/active), each host is connected via two paths, and the multipath driver on the host switches traffic over on failure. HPE states directly in QuickSpecs that the MSA 2060 does not support a single-controller configuration, and that updating controller firmware without downtime requires configured multipath. Dell ME5 also has a dual-controller architecture, but 2U models may be supplied with a single controller — check in the quote that there are two.

A NAS can also be made fault-tolerant. Synology High Availability builds a cluster from two devices: the active one constantly mirrors data to the passive one, and on failure the passive one takes over the services. But that means two boxes and two sets of identical drives, i.e. double the budget for capacity.

Neither a second controller nor snapshots replace backup. They protect against hardware failure, but not against file deletion, ransomware or administrator error. Copies live on a separate machine that is not part of the domain.

Growth: bays, shelves and the ceiling

A file server grows up to the size of its drive cage: 4, 8 or 12 LFF bays. With 22 TB drives, twelve bays give 220 TB in RAID 6. Beyond that — an external disk shelf via an external SAS controller, or a second server. The number of bays is fixed when the chassis is ordered, so it is planned for the data volume three years ahead.

HPE MSA 2060 and 2062 accept up to nine expansion shelves according to QuickSpecs: up to 120 LFF or 240 SFF drives in total, and LFF and SFF shelves can be mixed. Drives — only HPE MSA in their native drive trays.

Dell PowerVault ME5012 scales up to 264 drives according to Dell's specification — with nine ME412 or ME424 shelves or three ME484 shelves for 84 drives each; ME5024 — up to 276 drives. Snapshots and replication are included in the ME5 base delivery. On the MSA 2060, auto-tiering, 512 snapshots and replication are enabled by the Advanced Data Services license, while the MSA 2062 already includes it together with two 1.92 TB SSDs.

Shelf connection rules, generation compatibility and usable capacity calculations are covered in the selection guides HPE MSA 2060 and 2062 and Dell PowerVault ME5. A NAS device grows with expansion modules from the same manufacturer, according to its compatibility list.

Price per terabyte from catalog listings

Prices as of November 2026, including 12% VAT. Usable capacity — before formatting and without a hot spare drive.

Configuration

What's inside

Usable

Price

Per 1 TB

Office file server: Dell T350 8LFF, refurbished

4 × WD Ultrastar HC570 22 TB SATA, RAID 10 on the standard PERC H345, 4 bays free

44 TB

51,676,644 UZS

≈1.17 million UZS

File server or backup server: Dell R750XS 12LFF, refurbished, 2 × Xeon Silver 4310, 64 GB, PERC H755

12 × WD Ultrastar HC570 22 TB SATA, RAID 6, 10G network adapter

220 TB

137,014,226 UZS

≈623 thousand UZS

The same Dell R750XS 12LFF

12 × WD Ultrastar HC320 8 TB SAS, RAID 6

80 TB

94,100,460 UZS

≈1.18 million UZS

Dell PowerVault ME5012 SAS 12LFF, new

2 SAS controllers, 12 × 8 TB NL-SAS 7.2k, RAID 6

80 TB

price on request

—

HPE MSA 2060 iSCSI 12LFF, new

2 iSCSI controllers, no drives

—

93,084,000 UZS

HPE MSA drives — in the quote

HPE MSA 2062 iSCSI 24SFF, new

2 iSCSI controllers, 2 × 1.92 TB SSD, ADS license

flash tier

142,546,000 UZS

—

Dell PowerVault ME5024 iSCSI 24SFF, new

2 iSCSI controllers, 6 × 1.92 TB SSD

for VMs and databases

price on request

—

Drives in the server configurations are priced from catalog listings: WD Ultrastar HC570 22 TB SATA — 6,469,411 UZS, HC320 8 TB SAS — 3,234,705 UZS, Intel X520-DA2 two-port 10G network adapter — 4,097,294 UZS. A table of drives with the price per terabyte is in the selection guide on file servers.

The main takeaway from the table: a block storage system, even without drives, costs almost as much as a server with 80 TB — and that is before the hosts that will use it. With a SAS connection each host needs a SAS HBA; with iSCSI — 10/25G network adapters and switches. The money goes not to terabytes but to the second controller, non-disruptive updates and a shared volume for the cluster.

The cheapest terabyte is in a server with high-capacity drives: 220 TB for 137 million UZS. For archives, backups and video surveillance this is the decisive argument. How much space a camera archive needs is calculated from the bitrate and retention period — formulas and ready-made configurations are in the selection guide “Server for video surveillance”.

For virtual machines and databases, storage systems are chosen by IOPS and latency, so we do not calculate the price per terabyte for SSD configurations. For the MSA 2060 SAS, the price covers only the enclosure with controllers: the array accepts only branded HPE MSA drives, and we calculate their set and cost in the quote.

Who maintains it

NAS device. The system and applications are updated by the manufacturer, settings are in the web interface, and a generalist administrator can handle it. The warranty on such a box is provided by the seller it was bought from.

File server. You need an administrator with Windows Server or Linux experience: folder permissions, shadow copies, updates. Windows Server is licensed per core plus CAL client licenses; Samba and TrueNAS are free but require Linux skills. The hardware is visible remotely via iDRAC or iLO.

Block storage system. The administrator must understand multipath, the storage network (iSCSI or FC zoning), presenting volumes to hosts and the controller firmware update procedure. A mistake at the configuration stage — for example, a host connected via a single path — reduces the point of the second controller to zero. A spare drive is kept in the array from day one: a made-to-order branded drive takes weeks to arrive.

Servers and storage systems from the Servix catalog come with a warranty of 12 months — for both new and refurbished equipment, serviced by Servix.

How to decide: five questions

  1. Who consumes the data — people, or hypervisors and DBMS? People need folders, i.e. the NAS class. Two or more hosts with shared VMs need a block storage system.
  2. What does a day of downtime cost? If a day for repair is acceptable — one server or NAS plus a backup. If not — two controllers or a second identical device.
  3. How much data will there be in three years? Up to 220 TB fits in a server with 12 LFF drives; beyond that — storage system shelves or a second server.
  4. How many hosts will connect to the storage? Up to four — direct SAS; more — iSCSI or FC.
  5. Who will administer it? Without someone who understands multipath and the storage network, a storage system becomes an expensive disk shelf.

Frequently asked questions

Can virtual machines be kept on a NAS?

Technically yes: vSphere, Hyper-V and Proxmox work with storage over NFS or SMB. For testing and a small load this is a workable option. For production, the single NAS board gets in the way: its failure or reboot stops all machines.

Can files be shared directly from HPE MSA or Dell ME5?

No, both arrays are block storage. Folders are shared by a server or a virtual machine to which the array has presented a volume. For this, Dell supports pairing the ME5 with Windows NAS of the NX series.

Why are there no Synology and QNAP in the catalog, and what can replace them?

We do not sell them. The closest replacement is a tower server for 4–⁠8 3.5″ drives with Windows Server or Linux: for example, a Dell T350 with four 22 TB drives gives 44 TB for 51,676,644 UZS, and four more bays remain for growth.

Do you need a storage system if you have only one server?

No. For a single server, local drives are cheaper and faster. A storage system pays off from the second host in a cluster or when two servers must work with one volume.

Does a storage system replace backup?

No. Two controllers protect against hardware failure, snapshots against some errors. Only a copy on a separate machine outside the domain protects against ransomware and data deletion.

What is more cost-effective for a video archive?

For one or two recording servers — a server with an LFF drive cage and high-capacity drives. When there are many recording servers and the archive is measured in hundreds of terabytes, an LFF storage system with shelves, where each server is given its own volume, is more convenient.

Send to [email protected] a short description of the task: what will be stored (folders, backups, virtual machines, video, databases), how many users and hosts, the current data volume and annual growth, acceptable downtime and budget. We will select an option — a server, a storage system or a combination of them — and send a quote with prices in UZS. Warranty 12 months on new and refurbished equipment, serviced by Servix. Made to order — 2–⁠3 weeks, the price is fixed in the invoice. Free delivery in Tashkent, prices include 12% VAT.

See also: SAN, NAS or all-flash: how to choose a storage system for a company, How to choose a data storage system, File server and backup server, SFF or LFF: which drive bays to choose in a server.

Related reading